Westchester Power Program launches first-in-state energy aggregation

Something remarkable happened when the Sustainable Westchester team working on the community choice energy aggregation program opened the energy supply bids from leading energy service companies last month.

Clean energy won BIG!

In February 2015, the New York State Public Service Commission approvwestchester-map4ed Sustainable Westchester’s petition to pilot a municipal energy aggregation program in Westchester County with an order that enabled this first-in-New-York effort.

What is a community choice or municipal energy aggregation program?

In states with deregulated energy supply markets, energy service companies m
ay sell electric or gas supply to consumers. New York deregulated about twenty years ago. About seventy energy service companies are authorized to sell supply as a commodity to New York customers. Some are more scrupulous than others. Acquiring retail supply customers one at a time is expensive for the supply companies. As individuals, customers have no bargaining power with the suppliers.

When all the homes and small businesses in a city bid out their combined electric supply together, suddenly, economies of scale help both the customer and supplier reduce costs and increase rate choices. Community choice programs have been commonplace and successful in six other states, but now for the first time, in New York State as well.

Ever since the February order, the Sustainable Westchester’s team hit the road to visit with dozens of city, town and villages all across the County. Municipalities that were interested in joining the aggregation program needed to adopt local legislation enabling them to proceed. Benefitting from great pro-bono advisers, the team prepared draft legislation and resolutions to assist the municipalities.

Next, the team pre-screened energy service companies to identify those that best fit our criteria, such as transparent business practices, good customer service, creditworthiness and ample experience supplying community choice aggregation programs in other states. In addition, the team developed a comprehensive Electric Service Agreement with ample protections for the municipalities and consumers and worked with attorneys from twenty municipalities to finalize all the language.

The Westchester Power Program introduced a few conditions that went well beyond the February Order to benefit the consumers. First, the energy bid required that bidders accept the Electric Service Agreement terms and conditions verbatim. Second, bidders needed to provide a basic supply rate for a fixed period of no less than 24 months that would be lower than the benchmark of the average 2015 basic supply rate from the default local distribution utility (ConEdison or NYSEG). Third, bidders needed to provide a 100% renewable energy supply rate as well for that same period. Fourth, bidders had to allow individual customers in a participating municipality to leave or enter the program or switch between the two rates with no added fees or penalties.

By the time, the team sent out the Request for Proposals to the pre-screened supply firm, over 110,000 homes and businesses in twenty cities, towns and villages were included as potential customers. This buyers group represents four out of ten county residents, a remarkable feat of collective action all by itself.

The day the bids were opened led to a startling realization that both the basic supply rate and the 100% renewable supply rates were below the 2015 benchmarks from ConEdison and NYSEG.

“Suppliers who really wanted to enter the New York aggregation market stepped up,” notes Glenn Weinberg, the lead consultant. “In the end, buying 100% renewable energy green supply for the next two or three years will cost less than buying the basic, brown supply last year.”

By the time the program goes live in May, over 70,000 homes and small businesses will be buying 100% renewable energy supply in the fourteen cities, towns, and villages that chose to make that option the default for their jurisdiction. These customers “going 100% green” represent three out of ten county residents and, astoundingly, two-thirds of the entire 110,000 consumers in the program.

“Collectively, our consumers choosing the green option will buy 650,000 megawatt-hours per year of certified renewable energy credits,” states Leo Wiegman, Sustainable Westchester’s Executive Director, “That amount is the energy output equivalent to adding 84,000 residential solar systems in the county overnight.”

“Our instant market for clean, non-fossil, non-nuclear energy supply is the largest collective action in New York to date to address climate change and create real market demand for clean energy.” concludes Weinberg.

For more information, visit www.westchesterpower.org.


Happy Healthy Lawns

By: Larry O’Connell FCWC Board Member
It is spring and in a few weeks summer will be here, and we celebrate these seasons by inviting friends and family to outdoor barbecues and festivities.  We serve them delicious food and drink.
Other guests have already arrived at our banquet doorstep: crocuses, daffodils 8010448820_6644af638e_mand tulips as well as squirrels, songbirds, robins, blue jays and  butterflies and bees.  “How are do we provide their meal?”  Often with chemical fertilizers, pesticides, herbicides and other toxic materials via fertilizing lawns and gardens with commercial products.
As many of us realize, the chemicals in formulated, commercial fertilizers and pesticides are unhealthy, to  us, our pets and the wildlife that depend on our responsibility to be stewards to our environment.
So, this spring and summer, let’s go natural – let the dandelions flower – if ever drive along an upstate parkway and see the bright yellow dandelions contrast against the green grass – it is a wonderful and breathtaking sight.  OK – if do not like dandelions, then bend down and trowel them out – good exercise!
At FCWC, along with universities and conservation centers, we suggest the best natural fertilizer is from mulch taken from past years’ leaves, vegetable peelings, coffee grinds, etc. (no meat or egg products).  You can ensure this fertilizer is healthy – “You served it to your children!”
The science on the toxicity of these chemicals is well known, but often hidden from us, the public by the manufacturers and marketers.  As just one example, Professor Tyrone Hayes, of The University of California – Berkeley, studied the relationship of the herbicide atrazine on frogs.  He found the chemical altered the endocrine system of male frogs that feminizes the male frogs, while the company that manufactured the herbicide claimed no ill effects – for frogs or people.
Other studies demonstrate that grass or lawns develop an addiction to fertilizers, requiring more and more each year, much like a heroin addict, to maintain their greenery, but are less hardy and sustainable.  Other research show that sandy soil may require fertilizer; but the majority of Westchester County is not composed of sandy soil – so, wasting your money and time.
Let us become stewards of our natural environment where the flowers, birds and bees want to come to our banquet without the worry of being sickened – just like our human friends and family.  Let’s not purchase commercial products – the wondrous land has been long before us without our assistance.
In closing, let us welcome our friends and neighbors to a healthy and bountiful banquet, just as we do for ourselves – by avoiding commercial chemical treatments to our soil and lawns.

Federation Meeting 2016: A Major Opportunity for Westchester’s Environmental Community

March 2016 E-News

For those who came, FCWC’s 2016 Federation Meeting was a major opportunity for environmental organizations to directly talk to County and State level elected officials about the issues they care about – and the ones who showed up seized it.

Each year FCWC hosts a Federation Meeting for our member organizations to come together, build networks and share; but this year we decided to make the meeting a little more interesting. In addition to allowing for our traditional programming, we invited elected officials from the County and State level to discuss environmental legislation on the horizon, and then offered the attending organizations an opportunity to share about their work and issues of interest.

The meeting welcomed 9* elected officials and members of their staff from the County and State level – all of whom dedicated three hours to talking about environmental legislation. Additionally we were very pleased to have representatives from 29 environmental organizations from around the county who came to discuss their work, their concerns, and what help they could use from the policy-makers.

This meeting was simply invaluable because it was a dialog – not a lecture. Representatives from each organization were allowed time to stand up and deliver on their main projects and issues, the elected officials then spoke about those prompted concerns.

The panel of elected officials opened the meeting. Some key topics mentioned by the legislators included the need to pause and consider the risks of the Algonquin Pipeline Expansion and how it can affect Indian Point; the need to continue investment in renewable energy sources and alternative transportation methods and funding and programs are available statewide to address these issues; the hesitation and opposition to Governor Cuomo’s proposal for a tunnel that would connect Long Island with Westchester County; increased financial resources available to protect and improve inland waterways throughout Westchester, the New York State Water Infrastructure Improvement Act –which will help to cleanup local and regional waterways and the need to expand and diversify the environmental movement in Westchester.

The exchange between elected officials and organizations continued during the latter portion of the meeting, where the environmental community was given the opportunity to share their concerns. Some key themes mentioned during the meeting were: food waste and where it can go in the County; LED lighting in municipalities; Algonquin Pipeline and calling for a halt to the pipeline expansion; water issues including storm water infrastructure, rising waters, flooding, and watershed planning; the Complete Streets Program and how to implement more pedestrian-friendly and cyclist-friendly streets; the concern about nitrogen from fertilizers entering local waterways; the need to engage to communities that don’t traditionally have access to open space; and finally, the need to we need to help the next generation care deeply about these environmental issues in order to create the next generation of environmentalists.

Thank you very much to all who attended. Our speakers were informative and interesting, leaving attendees feeling invigorated and ready to get back to work. And again we thank all of the elected officials who joined the event, and are very appreciative of their fellow concern for the environment.

We plan to share a more comprehensive report of what was discussed at the Federation Meeting our website in the near future. http://www.fcwc.org


*Elected Officials in attendance:

Hon. Shelley Mayer

Hon. Steve Otis

Hon. Amy Paulin

Hon. David Buchwald

Hon. Sandra Galef

Hon. George Latimer

Hon. Andrea Stewart-Cousins

Hon. Frances Corcoran

Hon. Thomas Abinanti

Making a Sound Investment in Energy

March 2016 E-news


Some events over the last few weeks are a reminder that we should take pause to fully assess the energy sources that we, residents of Westchester County, are investing in.

Over the course of four weeks our backyard has endured a ‘radioactive’ water leak from Indian Point Energy Center, and a home-heating oil spill contaminating the Bronx River. Not to mention there has been the ongoing battle concerning the high-pressure natural gas AIM pipeline expansion, which has received countless calls demanding construction to be halted.

We think it is high time that we collectively take stock and reevaluate where we want our energy to come from.


Indian Point ‘radioactive’ water leak

Indian Point has been at the center of many contentious discussions for decades. The facility is aging, and for years there have been reports of cracks, spills, and accidents. On Tuesday, February 6th, it was reported that Indian Point recorded a severe spike in radioactive, tritium-contaminated water at several monitoring wells[i]. The follow-up tests done a few days later on February 10th noted that the highest concentration was 80% higher than originally reported.

This leak is a major concern; it potentially threatens the health of the Westchester’s residents and environment. Governor Andrew Cuomo has taken steps to address this issue, starting a state investigation into the nuclear facility[ii]. Entergy, the company that owns the Indian Point facility, states that this latest leak should be of no concern to the public.

Home-heating oil spill contaminating the Bronx River

On Saturday, February 28th as much as 600 gallons of home-heating oil contaminated the Bronx River[iii]when a truck delivering to an apartment complex in Yonkers began to leak.

Approximately 2,100 gallons of oil spilled onto the roadway, of which 600 gallons drained down the storm drain on the road.[iv] The Department of Environmental Conservation and the Coast Guard were notified, and are staying on top of the situation.

Let’s make a sound investment:

We know that accidents happen, due to either human or mechanical error, mistakes are a normal occurrence in our daily lives – we get it. However we also think that these latest events are a window into the real risks these energy sources pose.

Renewable energy offers significant public health and environmental benefits. Air and water pollution emitted by coal and natural gas is linked to breathing problems, neurological damage, heart attacks, and cancer; and replacing these energy sources with renewables has been found to reduce premature mortality and lost workdays, and reduced overall healthcare costs.[v]



We think it is time to seriously invest in safer, greener, renewable fuels and move away from potentially contaminating sources.

[i] Riverkeeper, Environmental and Health Organizations Call for Immediate Indian Point Shutdown (http://www.riverkeeper.org/news-events/news/stop-polluters/power-plant-cases/indian-point/environmental-and-health-organizations-call-for-immediate-indian-point-shutdown/)

[ii] LOHUD, NY to probe ‘radioactive’ water leak at Indian Point, 2/6/16 (http://www.lohud.com/story/news/politics/politics-on-the-hudson/2016/02/06/ny-probe-radioactive-water-leak-indian-point/79929984/)

[iii] LOHUD, Oil truck leaking near Bronx River, 2/27/16 (http://www.lohud.com/story/news/2016/02/27/oil-truck-leaking-near-bronx-river/81030662/)

[iv] DEC- DHSES Statement on Heating Oil Spill in Yonkers, NY (http://content.govdelivery.com/accounts/NYSDEC/bulletins/1399a46?reqfrom=share)

[v] Machol, Rizk. 2013. Economic value of U.S. fossil fuel electricity health impacts. Environment International 52 75–80 (http://www.ucsusa.org/clean_energy/our-energy-choices/renewable-energy/public-benefits-of-renewable.html#references)

Greening Your Blue Jeans

March 2016 E-News


Dungarees, Levi’s, daisy dukes, denim – whatever you call them, blue they use a lot of water.

We all wear blue jeans, they are an American staple. But what is less commonly known, is how heavily the textile industry relies on water. To make one pair of stonewashed jeans requires about 500 gallons of water to grow, dye and process the cotton[i].

Americans throw away about 11.1 million tons of textiles annually (clothes, blankets, towels, etc)[ii] – that is a lot of water going to waste. This concern is becoming increasingly more important as the south-western United States continues to face extreme drought conditions[iii]. Access to water is only going to become more difficult due to climate change and demand, therefore we need a solution. One that is becoming increasingly popular, especially in our area is textile recycling.

Textile recycling companies see an opportunity to capitalize on the old t-shirts and blue jeans being thrown away. SpinGreen is an example of one such company operating in the New York Metro Area. SpinGreen advertises that “a stained t-shirt can turn into a wiping cloth, lone socks can turn into pillow stuffing, old denim can be turned into housing insulation, and teddy bears can be turned into car seat stuffing…[iv]” By finding a use for this often discarded resource, SpinGreen and other companies have found a way to profit while keeping organic products out of landfills.

SpinGreen has customized bins set up at various locations throughout our area, and they even offer a Green Concierge service. Keep an eye out for one in your neighborhood!



[i] http://www.huffingtonpost.com/polina-groman/recycling-textiles-quench_b_5413363.html

[ii] http://www.huffingtonpost.com/polina-groman/recycling-textiles-quench_b_5413363.html

[iii] http://droughtmonitor.unl.edu/

[iv] http://www.spingreen.com/faq/

Eagles and the Hudson

By Kate Munz, Member Relations Coordinator

Photo Credit: NYTimes on 5th Annual Eaglefest

In honor of Teatown’s EagleFest, we wanted to highlight the star of the yearly event, the bald eagle.

In the Hudson Valley we are very lucky to share space each season with this majestic, and nationally famous neighbor. While can see bald eagles yearly now, this was not always the case.

Before the 1900s, bald eagle populations in New York were plentiful, as many as 80 nesting sites according to the State Department of Environmental Conservation. But by 1976, only one pair of eaglets remained. Environmental groups citied pesticides, specifically DDT, for the reduced numbers. During that year, the state began its Bald Eagle Restoration Project as an attempt to bring back the population.

Today, approximately 500 bald eagles winter in New York. The eagles migrate to this region, usually arriving in December, as waters freeze in Canada and Nova Scotia. Eagle concentrations peak in January and February; heading back to their nests by mid-March.

We’ve seen the return of our eagles due to clean air and water, ample food supply, and largely undisturbed stands of trees – as these are important elements that support breeding pairs of eagles. It is therefore essential that we maintain this important habitat. Together we can work towards open space preservation and watershed protection.

Learn more about what you can do by visiting this page: http://www.birdday.org/birdday/themes/2012-twenty-years-of-imbd/20-ways-to-conserve-birds